Guest Post: A response to my piece about Putin and World War 2

In a radical departure for ‘Three Thousand Versts’ I am publishing the first ever guest post (control freakery you see). Phil Larkin has kindly emailed a response to my article about Putin and WW2. It is much too well argued to be consigned to my inbox and Phil has kindly agreed to let me reproduce it here. I will respond to some of the points which it raises in due course.


I always find Chekov's contributions on Russia, her politics, culture, and national identity fascinating. Although I have travelled throughout Poland (which I love) the Baltic States, and the Balkans, Russia largely remains for me, in the words of Winston Churchill, a mystery, wrapped in a riddle, inside an enigma. Throughout my travels, however, I have seen examples of Russian culture, the beauty of Eastern Orthodox iconography being particularly striking. I firmly believe that too many Western statesmen fall into the same category as myself, namely, ignorant, vis-a-vis Russia, something which causes many problems in our world today.

In a previous addition to this blog, I noted the photos of the Moscow underground which I had last seen in pictures as a schoolboy. In a sense they are an allegory of the Stalinist regime during the 1930s until his death - with the gilded paintings covering what is, in reality, a grey and monolithic structure. I remember reading that much of the work was done by political prisoners, at high speed under extremely difficult conditions.

I managed to read Putin's speech on the Great Patriotic War, and do believe that it was significant that he seemed to repudiate the Nazi/Soviet Pact of 1939, and showed remorse for the massacre of Katyn, for which the USSR denied responsibility for decades. While he did not do so unequivocally (as we perhaps should not expect him to), it was at least a nod in the right direction. While there are limits to the worth of historical opinion when discussing the origins of World War II, the Western Powers were at least partly blameworthy for this Pact, since both Stalin and Molotov appeared to believe that it was the only way in which to gain time to prepare for a Nazi attack, which was, in truth, inevitable. Had the UK and France offered a lifeline to the USSR in the form of an alliance between the Munich Agreement and the invasion of Poland, then, quite conceivably, Hitler could have been contained. Churchill and others wanted this approach to be adopted, but were rebuffed by an increasingly arrogant and blinkered Chamberlain.

As far as Putin's article is concerned, there can be no quibble over the contribution which the indomitable Russian peoples made to final victory over the Nazis in Europe. Again, citing Churchill, Russian troops "tore the guts out of the German armies", and this does not include the immense sacrifices made, and privations suffered, by Russian civilians themselves. The "Great Patriotic War" was a defining moment in Russian history, and the courage which this country showed should be honoured unequivocally. To this extent I agree heartily with Chekov. Russians can, and should, feel great pride as well as sorrow for their role in World War II.

However, this leaves vast room for discussion over Stalin's role in the lead up to the Great Patriotic War, and Soviet behaviour towards other non-Russian nationalities towards the end of the war and after. It is possible that the USSR would not have suffered the early setbacks which they did against the Finns and Germans had not the paranoid dictator robbed the Soviet armed forces of some of their best brains in his pre-War purges. There can be no moral justification for the Soviet invasion of Finland in 1939, which also constituted an act of unmitigated and unnecessary aggression. A decade ago, on a visit to Warsaw, I saw the monument to the Polish uprising against the Nazis in 1945, and it galled me to think of all the ordinary courageous Poles who could have been saved had Stalin allowed his troops to relieve the city. Instead, the Russian armies stood back and watched as the Nazis slaughtered Polish citizens and tore Warsaw asunder. Two years ago I stood before the statue of President Edvard Benes in Prague, who died in lonely internal exile after the Soviet Union had engineered the takeover of his country and stifled democratic government in Czechoslovakia and the rest of Eastern Europe through murder, subterfuge, and rigged elections. Before Christmas 2007, with some friends, we came upon a tenement building in Budapest still pock-marked with bullet holes along its front, a remnant of the 1956 uprising. I still find the creation of the “Iron Curtain” in post-War Europe difficult to accept as genuinely necessary for the safety of the USSR, and think that Russia has much to answer for in its treatment of Central and Eastern European non-Russian nations.

Yes, it is true that Russia should be treated with appropriate understanding of her historical sufferings, idiosyncrasies and culture, and it is obvious that Russia now feels under threat and surrounded, but understanding is a two way process: the motives of those central and eastern European nations who have either joined NATO or seek to join the organization should also be put in context and understood. They are anxious about the intentions of their giant and powerful neighbour, and given some of the messages sent out by the Kremlin, and the strangling of proper democracy and free speech in Russia over the past decade, who can blame them? These are countries which, having experienced Soviet rule at first hand (and in some cases before this, Tsarist Russian rule), have at least as much fear about Russian domination as Russia has about being “corralled” in by NATO countries.

I believe that it is important that the West, while showing sympathy and understanding to Russia, should say what it means and mean what it says, and do so in a firm manner. After all, Khruschev only took the US seriously after Kennedy demonstrated that he was prepared to use force over the Cuban missiles in 1962. I believe that Russia both respects and, indeed, expects, a firm and forthright approach to be adopted by Western statesmen in their dealings with this vast nation.

Phil Larkin

Comments

Owen Polley said…
In response – firstly I must admit that I greatly enjoyed reading the piece, which is why I chose to carry it on the blog. It is thoroughly argued, elegantly written and shows a good grasp of history and culture in central and eastern Europe. I enjoyed, in particular, the metaphor of the metro for the entire Stalinist edifice. There is a lot of truth in this image.
Just to develop one or two points.
Phil largely concurs with my analysis of Russia’s special contribution during WW2, and I agree when he contends, ‘this leaves vast room for discussion over Stalin's role in the lead up to the Great Patriotic War, and Soviet behaviour towards other non-Russian nationalities towards the end of the war and after’.
There is a vast quantity of literature which points to the dictator’s inconsistent approach to the Nazi threat. Orlando Figes has demonstrated, in his book ‘the Whisperers’, that Stalin’s purges of his own military top brass, were not as irrational as is often supposed. Doubtless, however, they did make Russia ill prepared for the conflict ahead.
It is often suggested that Stalin did not believe that it was Hitler’s intention to attack the Soviet Union, after the M/R pact was signed. The evidence is patchy, but what we can say is that his immediate response, when an attack was imminent, was inadequate.
However, consistently, he HAD alluded to the inevitability of war with Germany, during preceding years. The timing certainly caught Stalin unawares, but it is reasonable to suppose that he had expected to be at war with Germany, albeit not in June 1941.
The least that can be said of Phil’s contention that Stalin’s mismanagement contributed to deaths on the Soviet side is that is fair. It is also reasonable to cite instances of Soviet aggression, whether it was expansionism during the Winter War, or tanks rolling into Budapest or Prague.
I understand entirely that nationalities which suffered oppression during Stalin’s regime, or later, have understandable anxieties about Russian revival. Although I think it is important to remember that the Russian people were also amongst the most frequent victims of totalitarianism.

When Phil argues that the west ‘should say what it means and mean what it says’ vis a vis Russia, I agree. But I would interpret such a call, also to carry with it a tacit message not to treat Russia as an exceptional case. I would merely point out that exceptionalism can cut both ways.

It is not unreasonable to expect Russia’s good behaviour, but then again, it is not reasonable to reflexively support Russia’s enemies, allowing their misdemeanours to slip of the radar. It is understandable that former Soviet republics want to join Nato, but it is also understandable that Russia no longer thinks an international military structure aimed at its interests is appropriate. If the Warsaw Pact were still active and had restyled itself as a bastion of security, would western countries be relaxed about its recruitment of new members at their borders? Of course not.

In order to normalise relations with Russia, we have to look at its concerns seriously, rather than dismissing them as paranoia. Whilst we need not ignore history, we cannot use it to justify exceptionalism.
Owen Polley said…
I should also point out that the current Russian regime is not, by any reasonable description, commensurate with the Soviet one. Which is a point worth bearing in mind.
CW said…
So Phil has jumped ship and abandoned the Dreaming Arm™ for a more lucrative career with 3000 Versts? I hope you’re paying him well, Chekov!

Russia still has a long way to go on the road towards a fully fledged democracy. They could start with free and fair elections and freedom of the press – accompanied perhaps by impartial investigations into the murders of Anna Politkovskaya and Alexandr Lebed. But with Putin and Medvedv in the pockets of the Mafia godfathers and gangster capitalists in Siberia, Chelsea, etc (allegedly!) in a symbiotic relationship of mutually beneficial corruption and money laundering I can’t see this happening any time soon.

In any case I don’t think the greatest threat to Russia is not NATO or the US, but their neighbours across the Amur river China.
Owen Polley said…
CW - is there a FIFA for blogs? I'll be banned from signing any new bloggers for two years. ;-)

I'm not sure about these 'godfather' allegations. Russia's problems with crime are well known, but they are substantially less pronounced post Putin than pre.
Stoffels du Plessis said…
It's a pity the Russians ended the cold war with the Americans, as we could have had Apartheid going for a few more years. The Americans backed us to the hilt when we took on the commies in Mozambique and Angola (generously armed by the Russkies of course), then they crumbled under international pressure from all the bleeding heart liberals who refused to buy our oranges in their supermarkets. Those were the days. I have fond memories of my days in the military in Ang under General Pierre Van Zuidenhout - a fine man indeed. A good bok to the backbone and he hated the Commies with a passion.
Anonymous said…
'Russia has much to answer for in its treatment of Central and Eastern European non-Russian nations.'

maybe not. In the case of the Hungarian uprising, I think we should recall that Hungary was on Hitler's side before and during the war, and that Hungarian troops fought in the USSR. Many of those who participated in the Hungarian Uprising were linked to the pre-war Hunagrian regime (Miklos Horthy's), and it is hardly surprising that the USSR did not a neighbouring country to have such people in government, only 11 years after the war had ended. My general point is that many of the CEE nations that now cast themselves as victims were not.
Anonymous said…
Dont touch WIKILEAKS, faked DEMOCRACY!!!
Thank you
Anonymous said…
valium antidepressant hair follicle drug test valium - can you buy valium in the uk
Anonymous said…
lorazepam without prescription ativan quick acting - buy ativan overnight delivery
Anonymous said…
tramadol online tramadol online fedex next day - tramadol 617
Anonymous said…
buy tramadol without prescriptions tramadol 400 mg a day - long does tramadol high last
Anonymous said…
cheap lorazepam ativan addiction - ativan for sale online
Anonymous said…
buy tramadol online tramadol buying online legal - buy tramadol online no prescription
Anonymous said…
klonopin online buy clonazepam cheap - klonopin 10 mg
Anonymous said…
generic tramadol tramadol vs codeine - tramadol online next day delivery
Anonymous said…
buy tramadol without rx tramadol for dogs addiction - where to buy tramadol in usa
Anonymous said…
buy klonopin online adderall klonopin social anxiety - klonopin no prescription needed
Anonymous said…
tramadol online buy tramadol online no prescription cheap - tramadol dosage dogs cancer
Anonymous said…
tramadol without prescription tramadol 50 mg pictures - tramadol get u high
Anonymous said…
cheap tramadol no prescription tramadol online consultation - tramadol dosage rabbits
Anonymous said…
buy ambien online ambien discount programs - ambien xc for sale
Anonymous said…
buy tramadol no rx buy tramadol online echeck - tramadol online fedex next day
Anonymous said…
buy tramadol no prescription tramadol 50mg hcl tablets - tramadol hcl 627
Anonymous said…
tramadol no rx buy tramadol online new zealand - buy tramadol online overnight cod
Anonymous said…
tramadol online tramadol red pill - legal purchase tramadol online
Anonymous said…
buy tramadol online tramadol 50mg for sale - tramadol 99.95
Anonymous said…
cheapest ambien ambien no rx needed - many ambien 10 mg overdose
Anonymous said…
buy lorazepam online ativan withdrawal hair loss - ativan zyprexa interaction
Anonymous said…
order tramadol no prescription tramadol dosage 10 lb dog - tramadol hcl gluten
Anonymous said…
tramadol online tramadol for depression - tramadol online bluebook
Anonymous said…
buy tramadol online tramadol dosage depression - buy tramadol overnight delivery
Anonymous said…
carisoprodol online soma 350 mg vs flexeril - some more drug_uses
Anonymous said…
buy klonopin klonopin side effects urination - klonopin dosage restless legs
Anonymous said…
cheap zolpidem ambien side effects if you stay awake - ambien medication wikipedia
Anonymous said…
generic ambien ambien cr for anxiety - zolpidem side effects sleep walking
Anonymous said…
legal buy tramadol online tramadol online overnight mastercard - tramadol hcl for toothache
Anonymous said…
buy soma online no prescription soma pill v - is soma a strong muscle relaxant
Anonymous said…
ambien pills ambien drug type - lexapro ambien drug interactions
Anonymous said…
buy tramadol india tramadolor 100 mg - can overdose tramadol kill you
Anonymous said…
tramadol online no prescription cheap tramadol on line - long does 50mg tramadol take kick
Anonymous said…
buy tramadol for dogs tramadol hcl for dogs - tramadol online safe
Anonymous said…
buy klonopin online klonopin withdrawal experience - klonopin side effects erowid
Anonymous said…
buy ambien online no prescription ambien tablets online - will generic ambien cr available
Anonymous said…
buy tramadol online tramadol cheap prices - tramadol 50mg overdose
Anonymous said…
buy ativan online effects of ativan addiction - buy cheap ativan
Anonymous said…
cheap soma online soma san diego deadmau5 - purchase soma online legal
Anonymous said…
zolpidem 10 mg ambien side effects bad taste mouth - maximum safe dosage ambien
Anonymous said…
klonopin without prescription klonopin breastfeeding - klonopin children anxiety
Anonymous said…
ambien online ambien benzo drug screen - ambien cr withdrawal
Anonymous said…
generic ambien ambien dosage for insomnia - ambien withdrawal protocol
Anonymous said…
buy generic tramadol no prescription tramadol hcl controlled substance - buy tramadol online mastercard overnight
Anonymous said…
buy viagra from canada buy viagra pills uk - can u buy viagra online
Anonymous said…
buy tramadol tramadol online rx - tramadol hcl 20mg
Anonymous said…
cheap clonazepam klonopin side effects nightmares - buy clonazepam
Anonymous said…
generic ambien ambien sleep trip lil wayne passion pit - ambien side effects night sweats
Anonymous said…
buy viagra online buy real viagra online cheap - buy viagra new zealand
Anonymous said…
buy ambien online ambien drug class pregnancy - ambien side effects heartburn
Anonymous said…
cheap viagra does viagra work with alcohol - can you buy viagra on ebay
Anonymous said…
cheap ambien cost ambien vs generic - ambien side effects aggressive behavior
Anonymous said…
ambien sleep buy brand ambien online - ambien cr savings card
Anonymous said…
discount klonopin klonopin 4 mg dosage - smoking klonopin erowid
Anonymous said…
order viagra professional viagra 50mg how long does it last - buy viagra online with paypal
Anonymous said…
klonopin online quitting klonopin cold turkey - klonopin dosage for panic disorder
Anonymous said…
buy soma online buy soma online no prescription - soma carisoprodol tablets 250 mg
Anonymous said…
tramadol online tramadol while pregnant - buy tramadol overnight
Anonymous said…
generic ambien ambien generic names - sleep walking from ambien
Anonymous said…
buy viagra 100mg buy viagra 50mg online - viagra online with prescription
Anonymous said…
buy viagra ebay buy viagra online with prescription - generic viagra in canada
Anonymous said…
viagra drug viagra buy singapore - buy viagra online legally
Anonymous said…
buy tramadol buy generic tramadol online - buy tramadol 200
Anonymous said…
ambien drug will generic ambien cr available - ambien side effects mood swings
Anonymous said…
klonopin online klonopin 2mg side effects - generic for clonazepam
Anonymous said…
buy viagra generic viagra cipla - viagra patent expiration
Anonymous said…
online ambien ambien overdose liver - generic to ambien cr
Anonymous said…
buy viagra cheap buy viagra online in the uk - buy real viagra online canada
Anonymous said…
carisoprodol soma generic soma with codeine - jugar cubo soma online
Anonymous said…
buy viagra online no rx buy viagra online in australia - taking viagra for women
Anonymous said…
soma sale cheap soma apartments - soma drug test time table
Anonymous said…
buy discount tramadol tramadol hcl 50 mg webmd - just pills order tramadol online
Anonymous said…
buy viagra online in usa viagra max dosage - most reliable online pharmacy viagra
Anonymous said…
viagra online buy viagra 100mg uk - viagra dosage and instructions
Anonymous said…
cheap generic viagra generic viagra with free shipping - how does viagra for women
Anonymous said…
cialis 20mg generic cialis online no prescription - cialis 70 ans
Anonymous said…
cheap soma online soma 350 mg is used for - soma bra
Anonymous said…
soma online soma pills abuse - soma bra reviews
Anonymous said…
buy viagra 100mg buy viagra from india - generic viagra delivered to canada'
Anonymous said…
tadalafil without prescription cialis 800mg black - buy cialis online in u.k
Anonymous said…
tramadol online tramadol help vicodin withdrawal - tramadol hcl 50 mg tab teva
Anonymous said…
buy tramadol online no prescription overnight tramadol withdrawal one week - tramadol hcl liquid
Anonymous said…
buy viagra online fast delivery order viagra online usa - buy viagra online uk
Anonymous said…
buy propecia generic propecia approved fda - propecia side effects to go away
Anonymous said…
buy viagra no prescription generic viagra online free prescription - buy viagra online low price
Anonymous said…
order cialis online no prescription cheap cialis generic india - cialis everyday reviews
Anonymous said…
cialis online buy cialis - cialis online 5mg
Anonymous said…
tramadol online order tramadol medication - what is tramadol ultram used for
Anonymous said…
propecia online pharmacy propecia+60 years old - propecia kopen
Anonymous said…
tramadol online cod tramadol overnight delivery to florida - what is tramadol 50mg tablets
Anonymous said…
cialis without prescription buy cialis taiwan - cialis buy
Anonymous said…
buy retin-a retin a wrinkles before and after photos - retin a micro 20 g
Anonymous said…
buy viagra without prescriptions buy viagra online cheap canada - online pharmacy viagra no prescription
Anonymous said…
propecia hair loss order finasteride - generic propecia cheapest
Anonymous said…
order viagra cheap buy viagra online tesco - cheap viagra aust
Anonymous said…
cheap tramadol buy tramadol pay cod - where to buy tramadol online safely
Anonymous said…
propecia mg propecia before and after hairline - propecia side effects after 1 year
Anonymous said…
buy viagra viagra 300mg - viagra online legit
Anonymous said…
buy tramadol cheap where to buy tramadol over the counter - tramadol 50mg tablets dosage
Anonymous said…
buy tramadol for dogs order tramadol dog - buy tramadol online usa
Anonymous said…
buy tramadol cod online tramadol 50mg vs 100mg - tramadol for dogs anti inflammatory
Anonymous said…
legal buy tramadol online safest place buy tramadol online - tramadol-ct 100mg retardkapseln beipackzettel
Anonymous said…
tramadol overnight shipping tramadol buy online cheap - cheap tramadol online no prescription
Anonymous said…
buy retin buy retin a gel 0.01 - buy retin a canadian pharmacy
Anonymous said…
tramadol 50mg tramadol hcl er dosage - buy tramadol cod
Anonymous said…
buy propecia online where to buy generic propecia online - propecia generic cheap
Anonymous said…
buy generic propecia much should propecia cost - propecia cost in india
Anonymous said…
buy tramadol online with mastercard buy tramadol cheap online no prescription - illegal buy tramadol online usa
Anonymous said…
generic finasteride propecia results young men - propecia results reviews
Anonymous said…
buy tramadol tramadol dosage daily - tramadol purchase cheap
Anonymous said…
tramadol online buy tramadol online overnight - buy tramadol line usa
Anonymous said…
strattera atomoxetine strattera erowid experience - strattera help with cost
Anonymous said…
tramadol online no prescription buy tramadol online with cod - do people buy tramadol
Anonymous said…
tramadol 50 mg tramadol for dogs with liver problems - 100mg tramadol vs percocet
Anonymous said…
buy tramadol online much tramadol overdose dog - buy cheap tramadol online cod
Anonymous said…
online pharmacy retin a retin a cream hyperpigmentation - purchase retin a no prescription
Anonymous said…
buy tramadol online no prescription overnight tramadol 50 mg medication - tramadol hcl time release
Anonymous said…
buy tramadol online no prescription cheap tramadol efectos secundarios - order tramadol online overnight delivery
Anonymous said…
tramadol 50 mg tramadol purchase fedex - tramadol overdose info
Anonymous said…
tramadol online tramadol 50 mg how many get high - can i buy tramadol in usa
Anonymous said…
buy cialis online cialis consumer reviews - buy cialis online fast shipping generic
Anonymous said…
buy cialis no prescription buy cialis daily use - buy cialis miami
Anonymous said…
generic viagra buy viagra online cheap us - most reliable online pharmacy viagra
Anonymous said…
buy tramadol tramadol 100 mg high dose - buy tramadol spain
Anonymous said…
cheap tadalafil cialis daily or as needed - cheap cialis prices uk
Anonymous said…
viagra online without prescription viagra mechanism of action - cheap generic viagra free shipping
Anonymous said…
cialis price buy cialis levitra viagra - should buy cialis online
Anonymous said…
cheap viagra real viagra online canadian pharmacy - cheap viagra that works
Anonymous said…
generic viagra something like viagra for women - buy viagra from us
Anonymous said…
order cialis online cialis online no prescription uk - cialis online authentic
Anonymous said…
cheap viagra buy viagra rio de janeiro - buy 200 mg viagra
Anonymous said…
cheap generic cialis cialis price uae - cialis daily dose reviews
Anonymous said…
viagra no prescription cheap viagra kamagra - purchase viagra online from us
Anonymous said…
generic viagra buy viagra us mastercard - allintitle viagra 6 free samples
Anonymous said…
viagra price legal buy viagra online us - order viagra and cialis online
Anonymous said…
viagra no prescription generic viagra available yet - buy viagra online usa
Anonymous said…
buy cialis cialis young men reviews - cheap cialis 40 mg
Anonymous said…
generic cialis cialis lilly - cialis price rise
Anonymous said…
tadalafil 20mg buy cialis online canadian pharmacy - generic cialis mississauga
Anonymous said…
generic cialis cialis 5mg price comparison - buy cialis safely online
Anonymous said…
viagra online viagra triangle bars - cheap viagra to buy
Anonymous said…
viagra online cheap viagra toronto - buy viagra online canadian pharmacy
Anonymous said…
buy cialis generic cialis mexico - buy cialis without rx
Anonymous said…
order viagra generic viagra online+overnight shipping - viagra online canadian pharmacy paypal
Anonymous said…
buy cialis how to buy cialis online - cialis online authentic
Anonymous said…
soma buy color soma pills - order soma without script
Anonymous said…
buy soma online effects of soma pills - soma online fedex
Anonymous said…
soma online soma wadhwa for sale childhood - legitimate online soma
Anonymous said…
buy soma online generic name for soma - rows at soma for sale omaha
Anonymous said…
buy soma san francisco soma lofts for sale - does soma generic look like
Anonymous said…
order soma online soma xpress 650b - soma drug movie
Anonymous said…
generic soma erin soma san diego - soma urban dictionary
Anonymous said…
retin a gel can you buy retin usa - retin a side effects peeling
Anonymous said…
buy generic tramadol cheap tramadol without rx - tramadol 50 mg high
Anonymous said…
retin a gel retin a micro gel .04 for wrinkles - retin-a micro week 7
Anonymous said…
tramadol 50mg ultram tramadol for depression - generic pill tramadol
Anonymous said…
buy tramadol online tramadol withdrawal youtube - tramadol 50mg slow release
Anonymous said…
retin a buy retin a for acne marks - cheapest retin a cream
Anonymous said…
cheap tramadol online tramadol dogs dosage dogs tramadol - tramadol dosage by weight
Anonymous said…
where to buy retin a micro retin-a cream 0.0025 - retin a acne how long does it take to work
Anonymous said…
tramadol 50 mg addiction to tramadol - can you buy tramadol over counter usa
Anonymous said…
buy tramadol 100mg cheap tramadol canada - tramadol dosage 100 lb dog
Anonymous said…
buy retin a where to buy retin a micro gel - retin a micro gel manufacturer
Anonymous said…
buy tramadol cod fedex tramadol much get high - tramadol hcl zoloft
Anonymous said…
tramadol 50 mg tramadol addiction time - tramadol canine dosage
Anonymous said…
cheap tramadol tramadol 400 - tramadol online us pharmacy
Anonymous said…
tramadol online tramadol for dogs allergic reaction - tramadol hcl withdrawal
Anonymous said…
buy tramadol hcl tramadol online health solutions - buy tramadol dogs online
Anonymous said…
tramadol online tramadol 50 mg strength - tramadol 100 mg slow release
Anonymous said…
Your own article fеаtuгeѕ veгified helpful
to myself. It’s eхtremely useful аnԁ уou're simply certainly extremely experienced of this type. You have got opened my personal sight for you to numerous thoughts about this particular subject together with intriguing and sound content.
Here is my website ; Ambien online
Anonymous said…
This web site definitely has all of the info I needed concerning this subject and
didn't know who to ask.

My blog :: Buy Viagra Online
my webpage: buy Viagra no rx
Anonymous said…
If a man is infertile he does not necessarily suffer from sexual dysfunction.

Cholesterol clogs arteries and allows less blood flow
to. Doctors can help cure erectile dysfunction by injection erection stimulating
medicine on the base of the penis.

Feel free to surf to my web blog - Buy Viagra Superdrug
Anonymous said…
The reροrt has confirmed helpful to myself.
It’ѕ rеally helpful and уou're simply obviously extremely experienced in this field. You have got opened my eye in order to varying views on this specific subject matter using interesting and solid articles.

My website - buy viagra
Also visit my website - viagra online
Anonymous said…
Your aгtіcle feаtuгeѕ рroven helpful to us.
It’s reallу infοгmatіve anԁ you're obviously really knowledgeable of this type. You have got exposed my face to varying opinion of this specific subject along with intriguing, notable and reliable written content.

Feel free to visit my blog post - http://culturerooms.com/index.php?do=/profile-80105/info/
Anonymous said…
Many thanks for the option. This worked great
!!!

my web page: www.isk-gbg.org

Popular posts from this blog

Football fever in Russia

Shia Revival

Walker loada rubbish