You can't be Scottish and British! SNP subscribes to Republican Sinn Féin's take on identity.

The minority SNP government in Scotland wishes to make it impossible to select both Scottish and British in the ethnicity section of the 2011 census. The people of Scotland would consequently be corralled into accepting nationalist absolutes when describing their identity. It represents nothing less than a further assault on the ability to define oneself in terms of a plurality of identities. It is a disingenuous one at that, seeking to deprive respondents of the option, rather than persuading them not to choose it.

Scottish Unionist highlights a particularly broadminded exposition of the SNP’s stance.

Comments

Anonymous said…
It's a conshpiracy! Er, I don't think so...

A Government Statement on Scotland's Census 2011, p27 para 3.46: "A separate question on national identity has also been added to complement the ethnic group question, to allow people to express their sense of 'Scottishness' 'Englishness' 'Britishness' etc (or any combination of national identity, for example 'Scottish' and 'British')
12 December 2008 at 18:13
Anonymous said…
Anonymous

Chekov was referring to the "ethnic group" section, not "national identity".

Page 34 of the census recommendation paper compares the "ethnic group" question for 2001 with that proposed for 2011.

In 2001, if "white", you had to choose one of these:

* Scottish
* Other British
* Irish
* Any other white background (write in)

The only really significant overlap there is for those Northern Irish who would prefer to reply "Irish" rather than "British" or "Northern Irish". Fair enough.

But for 2011, here is the proposal. Again, only one may be chosen:

* Scottish
* English
* Welsh
* Northern Irish
* British
* Irish
* Gypsy/Traveller
* Polish
* Other white ethnic group (write in)

This time we have major overlap. "British" is pitted against "Scottish", "English" etc.
13 December 2008 at 20:27
Anonymous said…
So perhaps to better reflect reality, the headline should scream "You can't be Scottish and British in one question, but you can in another" ?
15 December 2008 at 12:17
Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Football fever in Russia

Russia Blog is getting excited about Euro 2008. Indeed it is drawing parallels between Guus Hiddink and Peter the Great in terms of successful Russo-Dutch exchanges of expertise. Meanwhile, in Moscow, fans have been taking to the streets in order to celebrate the national team’s achievements.
Read more

Shia Revival

The Iranian author, Vali Nasr, has written an interesting book called The Shia Revival: How conflicts within Islam will shape the future .  Its argument is exceptionally pertinent at a time when European governments are edging toward arming Sunni extremists in Syria. Nasr portrays Shiism as the more liberal, palatable strand of Islam and a religion for underdogs.  He makes his point persuasively, although putting a progressive gloss on the regime in Iran and Hezbollah does undermine his thesis. A lot of the material is focussed on Iraq, where there is a Shia majority, which was suppressed during the presidency of Saddam Hussein.  The leading cleric, Ayatollah Sistani, is depicted as a moderating influence, who opposed retaliation as Sunni extremism threatened to cause sectarian civil war. The book’s opening chapter provides an erudite and fascinating history of factions within Islam.  The split dates back to the origins of the faith and a dispute over the prophet Mohammed’
Read more

Walker loada rubbish

Former BBC employee Brian Walker has overrun Slugger O’Toole lately with countless poorly structured, poorly written posts. It is possible quickly to recognize and avoid these by subjecting each Slugger piece to a cursory inspection and identifying those which feature characteristic lack of paragraphing and a tenuous grasp on the technicalities of linking source articles. Although I generally evade Walker’s posts by this method, occasionally (and unfortunately) I have persevered and found that their content is as unrewarding as the style in which they are written. Today, for instance, I inflicted upon myself Brian’s thoughts on a mooted Fianna Fail / SDLP merger . In actual fact, he is right to welcome news that the Southern Irish party has dropped this proposal from its agenda; however, the logic by which he arrives at this conclusion is parochial nonsense. To summarise, Walker believes that pursuing realignment with larger parties, whether they are from the rest of the UK or fro
Read more