Tuesday, 2 December 2008

Initial impressions of Calman - a temperate document

O’Neill and Little Man in a Toque have proved quick out of the blocks on the Calman Commission interim report. I’ve only made my way (rather swiftly) through the summary PDF but although the documents will require more scrutiny, it is worth sketching out a little of the detail and perhaps outlining a few initial thoughts. Apologies, but my assessment is rather rushed.

Firstly, notwithstanding the SNP’s attempts to establish unofficial separate Scottish representatives in foreign climes, the report is unequivocal in its recommendation that Westminster will “continue to be responsible for national defence and security, representing Scotland in international affairs”. It correctly asserts, “within a
nation state, this is clearly the right solution”.

The document does acknowledge that devolution offers a basis for different financial and welfare arrangements operating in different regions of the United Kingdom. However it infers that such variations might compromise common social citizenship and the uniformity of the UK’s common market.

Furthermore, it suggests that although there is some evidence to support the idea that broadcasting, energy policy, animal health and movement, firearms, misuse of drugs, regulation of health care professionals and marine planning might be more efficiently administered by devolving further powers to Scotland, it holds that there is not enough evidence to support a similar assertion for “the civil service; insolvency; employment law and relevant aspects of immigration; and health and safety”.

Significantly, examining the financial accountability of the Scottish Parliament, the commission found that current funding arrangements had got devolution off ‘to a good start’. It considers, “greater tax devolution would be associated with less shared social citizenship, while high dependence on grant funding implies some common expectations about the need for welfare services like health and education”. Its conclusions in this area are spot on. Scotland has benefited from the block grant, it is important that common expectations in terms of welfare are met throughout the United Kingdom and devolving further tax raising powers to Edinburgh would dilute the Union.

The commission believes that formal ‘machinery’ is needed to clarify the relationship between Holyrood and Westminster. It characterises the relationship during the course of the first two parliaments as ‘informal’. If further recommendations adhere to the principle which the commission sets out, i.e. “there ought to be an expectation that the Parliaments, Assemblies and Governments of the UK should work together in the common interests of UK citizens, even though there will sometimes be political differences between them”, such clarity might be beneficial.

The report sensibly maintains that there is no need for a second chamber in the Scottish Parliament. The scrutiny of committees and one chamber is sufficient, otherwise the sovereign parliament provides its own checks and balances. Scotland does not need the same constitutional safeguards required by an independent nation state.

Contrary to expectations, at first glance, this document appears to have much to recommend it. It is a relatively moderate, sober assessment of devolved Scotland’s place within the Union. Annabel Goldie contends the report establishes the commission as, ‘the most informed contributor to the devolution debate since the passing of the Scotland Act’.

If the Calman Commission’s interim report encourages a more temperate tone to the devolution debate, the body might just have performed an important function.

4 comments:

fair_deal said...

Only had a quick scan myself but it is a very interesting piece of work. plan to read the full report at the week-end.

Teeth whitening said...

Hi, all. Nice site. I really like your site ! Good job man.

Toque said...

Though it looks as though some people aren't too happy with the temperate tone.

will said...

A片,A片,A片,A片,A片,A片情趣商品,情趣用品,情趣用品,情趣,情趣,情趣用品,情趣商品,情趣用品,情趣,情趣,情趣用品,情趣商品,情趣用品,情趣,情趣,情趣用品,,情趣,情趣用品,情趣用品,情趣用品,情趣用品.情趣,情趣,情趣,情趣,視訊聊天室,情趣,情趣用品,情趣,情趣用品,情趣用品,情趣麻將,台灣彩卷,六合彩開獎號碼,運動彩卷,六合彩,遊戲,線上遊戲,cs online,搓麻將,矽谷麻將,明星三缺一, 橘子町,麻將大悶鍋,台客麻將,公博,game,,中華職棒,麗的線上小遊戲,國士無雙麻將,麻將館,賭博遊戲,威力彩,威力彩開獎號碼,龍龍運動網,史萊姆,史萊姆好玩遊戲,史萊姆第一個家,史萊姆好玩遊戲區,樂透彩開獎號碼,遊戲天堂,天堂,好玩遊戲,遊戲基地,無料遊戲王,好玩遊戲區,麻將遊戲,好玩遊戲區,小遊戲,電玩快打情趣用品,情趣,A片,AIO,AV,AV女優,A漫,免費A片,情色,情色貼圖,色情小說,情色文學,色情,寄情竹園小遊戲,色情遊戲,AIO交友愛情館,色情影片,情趣內衣,情趣睡衣,性感睡衣,情趣商品,微風成人,嘟嘟成人網,成人,18成人,成人影城,成人圖片,成人貼圖,成人圖片區,UT聊天室,聊天室,豆豆聊天室 ,哈啦聊天室,尋夢園聊天室,聊天室尋夢園,080苗栗人聊天室,080聊天室,視訊交友網,視訊借錢,黃金,黃金回收,黃金價格,黃金買賣,當舖,中古車,二手車A片,A片,成人網站,成人影片,色情,情色網,情色,AV,AV女優,成人影城,成人,色情A片,日本AV,免費成人影片,成人影片,SEX,免費A片,A片下載,免費A片下載,做愛,情色A片,色情影片,H漫,A漫,18成人,情色電影,自拍,成人電影a片,色情影片,情色電影,a片,色情,情色網,情色,av,av女優,成人影城,成人,色情a片,日本av,免費成人影片,成人影片,情色a片,sex,免費a片,a片下載,免費a片下載,成人網站,做愛,自拍A片,A片,A片下載,做愛,成人電影,18成人,日本A片,情色小說,情色電影,成人影城,自拍,情色論壇,成人論壇,情色貼圖,情色,免費A片,成人,成人光碟18成人,成人聊天室,成人電影,成人圖片,成人貼圖,成人圖片區,成人影片,成人文章,成人小說,微風成人區,成人交友,成人文學,成人漫畫,成人遊戲,免費成人影片 ,成人論壇,愛情公寓,情色,色情網站,情色A片,色情小說,情色文學