Monday, 31 March 2008

Duplicity and platitudes - the Bill of Rights.

Ten years after the Belfast Agreement the draft proposals for a Northern Ireland specific Bill of Rights are set to emerge today. Mark Devenport has got hold of a provisional copy of the report and has produced it in full on his BBC blog. I have been consistent in arguing that human rights are universal and that there are no human rights which need to be enshrined in legislation specific to Northern Ireland. Any bill will simply overlap existing provision for human rights and encroach on other areas of law for which the human rights remit is not appropriate. Unionists also fear that the bill will advance an agenda of diminution of Northern Ireland’s constitutional status under the guise of the rights agenda.

This fear is not simply unionist paranoia. Both unionist parties as well as the Alliance Party have expressed concern regarding the composition of the Bill of Rights Forum and are likely to record opposition to proposals in the draft report. Given Sinn Fein’s proclivity for advancing various agendas under the guise of rights and equality arguments (the altercation about the use of Stormont’s Long Gallery for instance) it is natural for unionists to be suspicious. The absence of a clear citation of anything approaching the generally accepted notion of a human right, which might require specific provision in Northern Ireland, has compounded this suspicion. The document which is about to emerge is unlikely to calm those fears.

There are a plethora of provisions dealing with areas already covered by legislation and indeed rights already enshrined by the Human Rights Act (1998) and the European Convention of Human Rights which that act codified in United Kingdom law. For example slavery looks set to be abolished under any Human Rights Act for Northern Ireland. There are vague platitudinous provisions covering abstract concepts which will allow rich pickings for the legal profession.

“Public authorities shall, when the circumstances so warrant, take special and concrete measures to achieve and sustain full equality”.


Wow! Full equality. If that is what we achieve in Northern Ireland through this proposed legislation and at the behest of public authorities, our little country will have become a fully fledged utopia. There’s nothing like setting the bar a little high! A little later we unearth the following sentence.

“The death penalty shall be abolished. No one shall be condemned to such penalty or executed”.


Whatever criticisms you may level at Northern Ireland, we do deserve credit for using the ultimate sanction so sparingly up to the point when the Human Rights Act will abolish it! You’d think with all those mass murders and bombings someone would have been tempted. Similarly the draft includes provisions outlawing domestic violence, sexual violence, harmful traditional practices, and sexual harassment - all of which are in very clear contravention of UK and EU laws anyway. The instances of this type of duplication are constant in this document. In fact nearly all the provisions which are concerned with actual human rights and the prevention of actual wrongs are duplicating laws enshrined elsewhere.

The Commission’s remit was to investigate whether there were special circumstances relevant to Northern Ireland which made specific provision for human rights necessary. This responsibility they have blatantly failed to fulfil. Most of the document has no special relevance to Northern Ireland whatsoever. The sections which can be argued to have some specific relevance stray far from the accepted remit of human rights legislation. We have a section covering indigenous languages which if adopted could smuggle in by stealth all the least savoury aspects of the mooted Irish Language Act. The chair’s proposed draft includes a ‘right’ to be educated in indigenous minority languages which would bind education boards not only to fund Irish language education from the public purse (as currently occurs) but would also require Ulster Scots education to be provided if any demand was to emerge. The expensive and needless requirement for public bodies to provide forms and speakers of these languages to communicate with those who insist that they must conduct their public business through such a medium is also contained in the chairman’s draft proposal. In themselves these things are highly contentious notions, in no way related to human rights, and it is patently wrong to saddle them on to legislation purporting to cover that area.

The section on nationality contains the seeds of disagreement too, although the chairman’s proposal finds a wording which does reflect the constitutional status of Northern Ireland.

“Everyone born within the jurisdiction has a right to British nationality and to recognition of any Irish nationality that he or she may hold.”


Although this clause does state the present position on nationality with a degree of accuracy (i.e. there is a right to British nationality with an option to simultaneously take up dual nationality in the Irish Republic), there is nothing new to be added to the Good Friday Agreement’s treatment of this issue. It does also reflect the possibility of people identifying their nationality in a nuanced way, but that is not a right of which people can be deprived in any case and it certainly does not need to be provided for in new legislation. If you have a right to free expression and a right not to be discriminated against on grounds of nationality then you necessarily also have the ability to define yourself as you wish. If governments in London and Dublin recognise you as a citizen entitled to a passport and allow for that in law, then those are all the citizenship laws that are needed.

Bizarrely the draft report then turns its attention to education, another area for which the state has been providing universal provision for more than 100 years. The chairman’s proposal would appear to guarantee us all the right to be educated in perpetuity. “Everyone has the right to an education and access to lifelong learning”. Given that only school age education must be provided for free will this effect any change or alter the status quo? In order to deprive people of the right to life long learning it would be necessary to remove their brain and/or lock them in a windowless room. What does this clause mean? We will only discover what it means if it is adopted in a bill, if it becomes law and if lawyers begin to pursue expensive litigation which will provide some manner of judicial interpretation.

One of the criticisms of the bill has been the assumption that its provisions would seek to establish economic rights. The argument is not that some measure of social security does not need to be provided in Northern Ireland, but that the extent of this should not be prescribed by human rights legislation. This is self-evident common sense, but if the report is an accurate indicator then the bill will nevertheless plough onward into this contentious area. The chairman has moderated an initial proposal which sought to enshrine a continuous improvement in living conditions. He has suggested improving conditions “beyond bare adequacy”, but even this accommodation could gain much in interpretation. What is ‘bare adequacy’ and what should the state be required to furnish people with in addition to providing adequately for their needs? This should be a matter for a democratically elected government, un-prescribed by legislation drafted by unelected quangoes. Economic policy is fundamental to the political choices which voters are asked to make at the polls. To circumscribe economic policy in this way is to diminish democracy itself.

The document deals with criminal justice in a great deal of depth, but the sections which would have most effect concern increasing the age of criminal responsibility to 18. The seriousness of that proposal has already been discussed at length elsewhere. The document takes an insidiously broad approach to defining victims of the troubles describing them as those who have survived “violent, conflict-related incidents”. This definition will clearly extend to those who have been involved in criminal and terrorist activity.

The document is long and stultifyingly bland. It will take more detailed perusal to draw out the full implications of its provisions. The overwhelming sense from the report is exactly what sceptics have been expecting. It is an exercise in duplication, in platitudes and in attempting to legislate outside the rights remit. There is no sustainable argument that these proposals should be the basis of a Human Rights Bill.

26 comments:

Hernandez said...

"In order to deprive people of the right to life long learning it would be necessary to remove their brain and/or lock them in a windowless room."

LOL. Great stuff. Nice piece.

The whole thing seems a nonsense to me. Yet more of the "please handle me with care as I'm from N. Ireland and am traumatised from years of terror/oppression from the IRA/Brits" crap.

Nevertheless, great to see the death penalty being done away with...

Anonymous said...

ugg france gfhvuogl ugg pas cher faoblnfd bottes ugg bqzxtggw ugg australia iplhmrvu bottes ugg pas cher ubkwnkuz ugg

Anonymous said...

cheap ugg boots sale dewytzkl cheap ugg boots uk yggrxzxh cheap ugg boots uzvcntkr cheap uggs sonucwrz ugg boots sale uk kxnfsfgt ugg boots sale wugqlurg ugg boots uk zbbazale ugg boots xnwbousm ugg sale bnpfmwwf

Anonymous said...

Thanks for every other wonderful post. The place else
may anyone get that type of information in such an ideal
manner of writing? I've a presentation next week, and I am at the look for such information.

my web page - Sidney Crosby Authentic Jersey

Anonymous said...

There is certainly a great deal to learn about this subject.
I love all the points you've made.

Take a look at my web-site zeroart-wallpapers.blogspot.fr

Anonymous said...

Hello just wanted to give you a brief heads up and
let you know a few of the images aren't loading properly. I'm not
sure why but I think its a linking issue. I've tried it in two different browsers and both show the same outcome.

Also visit my web site ... dominos Voucher code

Anonymous said...

You're so interesting! I do not believe I've truly read through anything like that before.
So wonderful to discover another person with
some original thoughts on this subject matter. Seriously..

thanks for starting this up. This site is one thing that's needed on the web, someone with a bit of originality!

Here is my site :: discount vouchers dominos

Anonymous said...

For hottest information you have to visit
internet and on internet I found this website as a best
site for latest updates.

Also visit my page Dominos Pizza Vouchers

Anonymous said...

What's up, the whole thing is going nicely here and ofcourse every one is sharing data, that's genuinely excellent, keep up writing.


Also visit my web site :: http://middleclassmillionaire.blogspot.de/2007/04/canadian-tour-of-personal-finance-blogs_18.html

Anonymous said...

Hello there! Would you mind if I share your blog with my
myspace group? There's a lot of folks that I think would really enjoy your content. Please let me know. Thank you

Also visit my web-site: Topbottomboys.com

Anonymous said...

I really like your blog.. very nice colors & theme.
Did you create this website yourself or did you hire someone to do it for you?
Plz respond as I'm looking to create my own blog and would like to know where u got this from. kudos

Feel free to visit my web page; fashion Jewellery Uk

Anonymous said...

I'm not sure where you are getting your information, but great topic. I needs to spend some time learning more or understanding more. Thanks for wonderful information I was looking for this info for my mission.

my weblog; care Home performance

Anonymous said...

I don't know if it's just me or if perhaps everybody else encountering problems with your
site. It seems like some of the text on your content are running off the screen.

Can somebody else please provide feedback and let me know if this is happening to
them as well? This may be a issue with my browser because I've had this happen before. Appreciate it

My webpage Care home management

Anonymous said...

Now I am going away to do my breakfast, after having
my breakfast coming yet again to read more news.

my site: Http://Video.Americanaddictthemovie.Com/Read_Blog/2374/Ways-To-Use-When-You-Make-A-Jewelry-Purchase

Anonymous said...

Now I am ready to do my breakfast, later than having my breakfast coming over again to read further news.


Feel free to visit my web site: Dominos codes 2011

Anonymous said...

Quality articles or reviews is the crucial to invite the people to pay a visit the website, that's what this website is providing.

Also visit my web-site :: aquamira.com

Anonymous said...

Incredible points. Great arguments. Keep up the good work.



Feel free to visit my weblog dominos voucher codes jan 2013

Anonymous said...

My family always say that I am killing my time here at net, except
I know I am getting know-how every day by reading such pleasant articles.


Also visit my blog post :: dominos voucher codes 50 off £30

Anonymous said...

Hello, i think that i noticed you visited my site so i came to go back the desire?
.I'm trying to in finding things to improve my web site!I assume its good enough to use some of your ideas!!

my weblog :: http://www.Hindusocialmedia.com/

Anonymous said...

Excellent way of explaining, and nice piece of writing to obtain data
about my presentation subject, which i am going to convey in academy.


Look at my site care home Performance

Anonymous said...

I'll immediately clutch your rss feed as I can not to find your e-mail subscription hyperlink or newsletter service. Do you have any? Please permit me recognize in order that I may subscribe. Thanks.

Review my homepage http://www.fooditud.com/blogs/240501/263618/save-money-every-week-with-these

Anonymous said...

You actually make it appear really easy together with your presentation but I find this topic to be really one thing which I believe
I might by no means understand. It kind of feels too complex and very extensive for me.
I am looking forward for your subsequent publish, I will try to
get the hang of it!

Stop by my web page - Discount Voucher Codes Dominos

Anonymous said...

I am truly happy to read this blog posts which carries
lots of helpful facts, thanks for providing these kinds of
statistics.

Have a look at my blog post ... tedxyse.com

Anonymous said...

Amazing blog! Do you have any tips for aspiring writers? I'm hoping to start my own website soon but I'm
a little lost on everything. Would you propose starting with a free
platform like Wordpress or go for a paid option? There are so many choices out there that
I'm totally confused .. Any tips? Thank you!

Here is my web-site :: Gafas De Sol Oakley

Anonymous said...

Hey would you mind stating which blog platform you're using? I'm looking to start my
own blog soon but I'm having a hard time choosing between BlogEngine/Wordpress/B2evolution and Drupal. The reason I ask is because your design seems different then most blogs and I'm looking for something completely unique.
P.S My apologies for getting off-topic but I had to
ask!

Feel free to surf to my blog: Oxford individual Tuition

Anonymous said...

Hello my friend! I wish to say that this post is amazing, great written and include almost all vital infos.
I'd like to peer more posts like this .

my website - http://slc-wireless.com/air-jordan-pas-cher.html