Tuesday, 18 September 2018

Ditch the dogma - do the deal

In the imagination of remainers, the Tory European Research Group is a cadre of irreconcilable Brexit ultras, determined to wrench the UK from the EU in chaotic fashion. It’s ironic then, that the ERG’s latest paper is one of the calmest contributions to the Irish border debate, delivering low-key, rather technical solutions to practical problems raised by the frontier, rather than overheated rhetoric.

The document draws heavily on the work of Dr Graham Gudgin, the Cambridge University academic who has examined forensically Brexit’s potential impact in Ireland at the think-tank, Policy Exchange. The audience at its publication included two former secretaries of state for Northern Ireland, Owen Paterson and Theresa Villiers, as well as Lord Trimble, unionist architect of the Belfast Agreement.

The ERG’s aim in writing this paper was fairly straight-forward. Come up with a set of arrangements that will avoid the need for new physical checks and infrastructure at the border between Northern Ireland and the Republic, without compromising the integrity of the customs union or the single market and without requiring the UK or parts of the UK to remain under the auspices of Brussels.

The broader purpose is to allow the two sides in the Brexit negotiations to get round the Irish road-block and start putting together a wide-ranging free trade agreement between the UK and the EU.

Unfortunately, the document was always likely to get a hostile reception, because the border question is no longer really about solving practical problems. Northern Ireland and its peace process are being exploited shamelessly to promote competing visions of Brexit.

The European Commission’s negotiating strategy is founded on portraying Britain’s departure from the EU as a binary choice between leaving the single market and the customs union or maintaining a soft border. Theresa May assisted Brussels by offering an unilateral commitment before talks began that there would be no additional checks or technology on the Irish frontier, under any circumstances. 
That has allowed Michel Barnier to maintain that, if her government insists on a meaningful Brexit, then it must agree to an internal UK border in the Irish Sea, while Northern Ireland must remain subject to the EU’s rules and customs regime.

For her part, the prime minister has used Brussels’ uncompromising stance to promote her Chequers’ plan for a diluted form of Brexit. Theresa May claims that the UK must accept a ‘common rulebook’ with the EU on goods and agriculture, in order to avoid an internal frontier. She even went so far as to say that anything that undermines a ‘seamless border’ on the island of Ireland is a “breach of the spirit of the Belfast Agreement.”

It was particularly disappointing to hear the prime minister join the growing number of culprits who have made erroneous claims about the Good Friday deal, since the EU referendum result. The deranged peer, Lord Adonis, claimed this week that certain types of Brexit would be “illegal” under the accord. None of these people can ever cite the text to support their arguments, whereas Lord Trimble, who knows the Belfast Agreement back to front, points out that the main threat to its central ‘principle of consent’ is an Irish Sea border.

If the ERG’s document has a flaw, it’s that it takes the various arguments about Ireland at face value. It attempts to address Mr Barnier’s claims that the single market cannot be protected, unless Northern Ireland remains under its tutelage. It shows Theresa May that Chequers is not the only way to keep trade flowing freely, both north to south and east to west.

In truth, neither the Irish border nor the Belfast Agreement form an impediment to any form of Brexit. The Chequers’ proposals must stand on their own merit and be weighed against the ERG’s ideas for a looser arrangement, based on a free trade agreement. It’s time for all sides to ditch the dogma around Ireland and get on with brokering a deal.


First published at This Union and Think Scotland.

26 comments:

Anonymous said...


There is a new easy way to make cool cash.Email: atmmachinehackes Its
all about the BLANK ATM CARD. This card can withdraw nothing less than $5,000(two thousand dollars) in a day. This card works in any country and with any currency. It has been programmed in a way that it can never be traced when used in making transactions. The card will make the security camera malfunction at that particular time until you are done with the transaction you can never be trace. Any one interested in the card should contact the programmer via his email address: atmmachinehackes@gmail.com or whatapp me on +1(641)328-8037

Sagarika Kumari said...

the pertinent stuff which I ran over in your review.
Kolkata Escorts Services
Escorts Services in Kolkata
Kolkata Escorts

viplahoregirlspk said...

We Have Best Post and very helpful so Open My link Lahore Escorts and you need a service so then call me and you need a other citys services so open this links
Escorts in Islamabad
Escorts in Karachi

fangdada said...

chicago massage

fangdada said...

atlanta massage

Zoya said...

Thanks for sharing great information. Contact Me For Indian Escorts in Malaysia, Pakistani Escorts in Malaysia, Malaysia Escorts, Escorts in Malaysia and Much More Escorts Service.

escortsgirlsdoha said...



Indian Escorts in Doha
Call Girl in Doha
Muscat Doha
Doha Call Girl
Escort Doha

escortsmuscat said...



Indian Escorts in Muscat
Call Girl in Muscat
Muscat Escorts
Muscat Call Girl
Escort Muscat

callgirlsmuscat said...



Indian Escorts in Muscat
Call Girl in Muscat
Muscat Escorts
Muscat Call Girl
Escort Muscat

callgirlsmuscat said...



Indian Escorts in Doha
Call Girl in Doha
Doha Escorts
Doha Call Girl
Escort Doha

Escorts in Lahore said...

Web are providing best escorts services in Lahore Pakistani escorts agency.


Escorts in Lahore
Escorts in Lahore
Escorts in Karachi
Escorts in Islamabad
Pakistani Escorts

Escortsinislamabad said...

escorts in Islamabad
escorts provider in Islamabad
best escorts girls in islamabad
escort in dubai or call gril in dubai
escort provider in pakistan
call girls in india provider
call girls in kabul
call grils in bangla call now
call grils lahore
call in kabul
escorts in uae
escort in islamabad
escort in punjab
escorts provider
vip escortad in Islamabad

Escortsinislamabad said...

escorts in islamabad
escorts provider in Islamabad
best escorts girls in islamabad
escort in dubai or call gril in dubai
escort provider in pakistan
call girls in india provider
call girls in kabul
call grils in bangla call now
call grils lahore
call in kabul
escorts in uae
escort in islamabad
escort in punjab
escorts provider
vip escortad in Islamabad


escorts provider in Islamabad
best escorts girls in islamabad
escort in dubai or call gril in dubai
escort provider in pakistan
call girls in india provider
call girls in kabul
call grils in bangla call now
call grils lahore
escorts in uae
escort in islamabad
escort in punjab
escorts provider
vip escorts in Islamabad

Eiliza45 said...

I love this post.

โปรโมชั่นGclub ของทางทีมงานตอนนี้แจกฟรีโบนัส 50%
เพียงแค่คุณสมัคร Gclub กับทางทีมงานของเราเพียงเท่านั้น
ร่วมมาเป็นส่วนหนึ่งกับเว็บไซต์คาสิโนออนไลน์ของเราได้เลยค่ะ
สมัครสมาชิกที่นี่ >>> Gclub online

lggy1688 said...


Very cool!

เว็บไซต์คาสิโนออนไลน์ที่ได้คุณภาพอับดับ 1 ของประเทศ
เป็นเว็บไซต์การพนันออนไลน์ที่มีคนมา สมัคร Gclub Royal1688
และยังมีเกมส์สล็อตออนไลน์ 1688 slot อีกมากมายให้คุณได้ลอง
สมัครสมาชิกที่นี่ >>> Gclub Royal1688

Kristen Stewart said...

Avast Support
Norton Phone Number
Mcafee Customer Service
Malwarebytes Support

Escortsinislamabad said...

escorts in india
escorts provider in Islamabad
best escorts girls in islamabad
escort in dubai or call gril in dubai
escort provider in pakistan
call girls in india provider
call girls in kabul
call grils in bangla call now
call grils lahore
escorts in uae
escort in islamabad
escort in punjab
escorts provider
vip escorts in Islamabad

my name said...

escorts in Islamabad
provider in Islamabad
escorts girls in islamabad
escort in dubai or call gril in dubai
escort provider in pakistan
call girls in india provider
call girls in kabul
call grils in bang
escorts in uae
escort in islamabad
escort in punja
vip escortad in Islamabad

my name said...

escorts in Islamabad
provider in Islamabad
escorts girls in islamabad
escort in dubai or call gril in dubai
escort provider in pakistan
call girls in india provider
call girls in kabul
call grils in bang
escorts in uae
escort in islamabad
escort in punja
vip escortad in Islamabad

Dale Morris said...

Norton phone number
McAfee Phone Number
Malwarebytes support phone number
Hp printer support phone number
Canon printer support number

Clipping Path Service said...

Great post.thank you so much.Love this blog.

Norton.com/setup said...

www.avg.com/retail – We need to share the important thing that we are the third party and provide independent support service and if you face any issue or trouble during the process you may contact AVG tech support to activate or install AVG products. You just need to fill the required blanks in form and our AVG Support will contact you as quick as possible.

123.hp.com/setup | www.avg.com/retail

Unknown said...

Cyberturbo do all kinds of related hacking and cyber works
We give 100% satisfaction and confidential to our clients
We do : * Surveillances
* Hacking of social
media e.g
Facebook, Instagram,
Snapchat
Hangout , emails etc
* Recovery & deleting of
all kinds
of records e.g CCTV
footage,
files evidence
* Upgrade of all kinds
of school
results either high
school,
Colleges, University (
Don't
have to stress
Yourself with much
study)
* Encrypt and decrypt of
all kinds
of documents including
all
multimedia
* Blank cards
* Crypto currency e.g bitcoin
* Bank transfer and western union transfer
We do these and more
Contact us @: Cyberturbosecure@gmail.com

VIP Girl in Pakistan said...

Dear clients, VIP Girl in Pakistan are responsible to give a perfect offer of meeting and enjoying famous models Escorts in Islamabad. The elite class clients who are giving most significance to the individual privacy are future us only. They will never get such a perfect safety while enjoy with top class Escorts in Islamabad.
http://vipgirlinpakistan.com/

Bernard Cypher said...

Hacking is very much easy as it is done in the movies we watch, Hackers are really able to do all those stuffs we see, like breaking into a 💻 network to gain access to certain files, to steal those file, monitor users actives, delete files and lots more.

HOW HACKING REALLY WORKS
Hacking is easily done by the use of specific programs (Computer virus, Spywares, Trojans, Malwares) to gain access and control over a 💻 and Cell 📲 . These programs are designed to break into computer defense without users even knowing it.

COPE TECHS SERVICES
COPE TECHS is an organization you can trust and contact if you need Hacking services. Our aim is not to help individuals who have technological problems and not for Thefts purposes. We guarantee you a 💯 % assurance of our job and for no reason will our work for you be exposed to someone else. Prove of our works in the past will be show to you but please note that the individuals we did them for won’t be disclosed to you.

HACKING SERVICE WE CAN OFFER YOU
There is no limits to what we can do for you but we have a restriction in things we can do. For no reason will we help you in Robbery or Stealing if someone’s else belongings and properties, please put that in mind.
Here is a list of our Approved services-:
*Hacking of Phones 📱 or Computer 💻 for the purpose of monitoring Emails📧, Text messages✉️, Phone calls📞, Social Media Chats💝, if suspected your spouse is cheating or doing something you not okay with.
*Repayments of Debts💵 to Banks and other Loan Companies, Yes with the help of Bitcoin💰 mining we have helped so many individuals repay debts.
*Changing of University Grades for students🗞, we can help with this because we know how hard studying can be and we all know that without good grades individuals are limited to the kind of job they can secure. and lots more.
If you don’t seem to find a Service you need feel free to ask us and if it’s not against our rules we will help you with it. Contacts is made only by email this helps us stay safe and untraceable.
Contact-:
copetechs@gmail.com

smith warner said...

Hello, I'm Smith Warner. If you are facing issues with mcafee(mcafee.com/activate), norton(norton.com/setup) and office(office.com/setup) product. then you can visit my website.